Why Your Productivity System Is Working Against You
It’s Sunday afternoon and you’re scrolling YouTube. You just discovered another "life-changing" productivity hack. Your pulse quickens. This could be the missing piece that finally gets you on top of everything.
Sound familiar?
We've created a false binary around productivity. You're either team "hack your way to success" or team "productivity culture is toxic." But like most either-or thinking, this misses the point entirely.
Productivity isn't inherently good or bad—it's a tool. And like any tool, its value depends entirely on the context.
The First Trap
Here's where most people get stuck: they collect productivity systems like Pokemon cards, hoping that somehow, magically, doing more will transform into being more. If you're in the first camp—still optimistic about finding the perfect system—you're likely here, full of hope and convinced the next system will be different.
The problem arises from the fact that we are implementing systems haphazardly without asking: What exactly am I trying to achieve and how will this help me achieve it? Without clear goals, productivity tactics become the strategy itself to achieve some vague goal of being “successful”.
At best, you're making random progress in random directions. At worst, you're expertly optimising your way toward someone else's definition of success.
The Second Trap
Even when you do have goals clearly defined, there's a second trap waiting: you don’t realise or refuse to accept that there is opportunity cost in life. This is where the second camp—those who've become disillusioned with productivity culture—often ends up. They've tried cramming everything in, hit the wall of their finite life resources, and concluded that productivity itself is toxic.
The reality is that your life resources are limited. Every yes is simultaneously a no to something else. Yet we resist this reality, believing we can transcend our limitations through better systems and harder work.
Eventually, that crushing realisation arrives. The productivity system that was supposed to simplify everything has now created even more work.
This creates what Oliver Burkeman calls the productivity trap:
"Productivity is a trap. Becoming more efficient just makes you more rushed, and trying to clear the decks simply makes them fill up again faster."
What Actually Works
The path out requires two foundational misconcepts:
Define your own arbitrary life goals: Without this foundation, every productivity tactic becomes elaborate busy work. Your arbitrary life goals act as the metric to guide your decisions against.
Embrace opportunity cost: You cannot do everything. The question isn't how to fit more in—it's how to choose better. With your goals to guide you, you can make better opportunity cost assessments on which productivity tactics to take on board, if at all.
When you're clear on both, productivity tactics transform from complicated life-management contraptions into tools with a clear purpose. Your productivity system should serve your goals, not distract you from it
Making the Change
The next time you feel pressured to execute on your complex productivity system, pause and ask:
"Is my current system serving my goals, or have my goals become serving this system?"
If the answer makes you uncomfortable, that's your signal.